College Life Archives - Slap the Scissors

Why a (Christian) Liberal Arts Education?

Terry Sergeant — Tue, 07 Aug 2018 16:26:32 +0000

Greatest Thought

James B. Simmons: “What is the greatest thought that has ever occupied your mind?” and, “What is your duty toward fulfilling it?”

This is a rock. How many sides does it have?

Two? (top/bottom)
Six? (sort of a rectangular prism)
Thousands?
Millions?

This is a sign at the entrance of the “Ancient Americas” exhibit in the Field Museum (Chicago).

The sign says: “The Ancient Americas is a story of diversity and change — not progress”
The Field Museum has an emphasis on natural history.
The “About” section of their website (https://www.fieldmuseum.org/about) ends with these words: “Science is for everyone. And we can’t wait to share it with you.”
Why would a a “science” museum put an opinion at the entrance of their exhibit?

This chart is from an NPR News article: “Is Sleeping With Your Baby as Dangerous as Doctors Say?”

The author of the article makes the following points:

some parents choose to sleep with their infants (regardless of recommendations)
removing the stigma associated with this practice will provide more opportunities for health-care professionals to give guidance for safer bed-sharing practices
low-risk babies are very low risk … and multiplying a very low risk by 3 (er … 2.8) is still a low risk

Then this chart!?!

1 in 46,000	chance of a low-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in a crib in parent’s room
1 in 16,400	chance of a low-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in parent’s bed
1 in 13,000	chance of being hit by lightning in the U.S. in a person’s lifetime
1 in 9,100	chance of being killed in a car accident in the U.S. in a year
1 in 4,400	chance of drowning before turning 18
1 in 1,500	chance of a high-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in a crib in parent’s room
1 in 150	chance of a high-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in parent’s bed
1 in 50	chance of developing a peanut allergy as a child

There are quite a few issues I have with this chart and the conclusions that supposedly can be drawn from it:
- Why “chance of lightning strike in lifetime” rather than “chance of death by lightning strike in a year”?
- Why is “peanut allergies” on the list?
- Why is “chance of drowning” spread over 18 years (when SIDS is a one-year risk)?
If parents in the U.S., encouraged by this article, systematically adopted bed-sharing with infants, it would result in dozens of infant deaths that otherwise would not have occurred!
Why would a reputable news agency consider this a good article to publish?

This is the same chart with a couple of lines added by me.

1 in 1,000,000	chance of U.S. high school student dying in a school shooting in 2017 (wikipedia)
1 in 79,200	chance of drowning in a year
1 in 46,000	chance of a low-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in a crib in parent’s room
1 in 16,400	chance of a low-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in parent’s bed
1 in 9,100	chance of being killed in a car accident in the U.S. in a year
1 in 7,100	chance of U.S. teenager committing suicide in a year (Huffington Post)
1 in 5,000	chance of dying from drug overdose in a year (drugabuse.org)
1 in 1,500	chance of a high-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in parent’s room
1 in 150	chance of a high-risk baby dying of SIDS while sleeping in parent’s bed

I removed peanut allergy and lightning strike stats (irrelevant).
I amortized the drowning statistic to make it per year (rather than over an 18 year period). Reason: SIDS is typically a one-year risk.
I added (highlighted) other statistics, the first of which reveals a flaw in the logic used by the article’s author.
The stats regarding suicide and drug overdose are especially striking: Their prevalence is concerning and the fact they are self-induced harm suggests we are facing a “crisis of purpose”.

What do a rock, a sign, and an article about SIDS have to do with a liberal arts education?

We are bombarded with information, misinformation, and persuasive messaging constantly.
In these examples we have a “news” organization publishing something that is not news and is harmful to the public health. And we have “science” museum presenting something that is not scientific.
At times we may agree with those messages and at times the messages may be in our best interest.
A liberal arts education provides a cognitive framework to parse and dissect this messaging.
What makes a distinctively Christian liberal arts education valuable is that we have foundation from which to engage a world in the midst of a crisis of purpose.
So, what’s up with the rock?
There is a bizarre notion that every “issue” has exactly two sides. If a simple rock has thousands of discernible faces then why would a complex social issue have only two sides?

My Conclusion

Our society needs educated, thinking, articulate people to counteract the tsunami of false/slanted/persuasive messaging.
Our society needs the hope and purpose that the Christian faith offers to counteract the crisis of self-inflicted harm.

The post Why a (Christian) Liberal Arts Education? appeared first on Slap the Scissors.

Worldview Matters: Introduction

Terry Sergeant — Mon, 21 Jan 2013 23:31:48 +0000

In my post Why Students Fail, I ended by making the claim that one’s wordview matters. I also suggested that for some students, their worldview has an impact on whether or not they graduate from college and on what they get out of their education. This is the first of a series of posts that goes into more detail as to why your worldview matters and what your worldview entails. The book, How Now Shall We Live? by Charles Colson is a helpful introduction to this topic and I will be using it as a basis for this series.

What is a “Worldview”?

According to Colson, a person’s view of how the world works needs to answer three questions:

Where do we come from?
What is wrong with the world?
What can be done to fix it?

It is interesting that the questions Colson suggests, presuppose his own worldview. For example, the third question assumes he believes we have a responsibility to try to fix what’s wrong with the world. I happen to agree with him on that point. In that regard, perhaps the first question represents the crux of a person’s worldview. How you answer that question will determine what questions are to be asked next. For example, if your answer to the question “Where do we come from?” is “We are products of evolution caused by the random forces of matter over time”, then it seems to me the next question would be something like “Is there any purpose to my life?” More than one philosopher has concluded that there is, indeed, no purpose, going so far as to suggest that the only logical course of action is to, upon realizing that fact, kill oneself. Of course, it makes me wonder how the same philosopher came to write a book about the topic!

What is a “Christian Worldview”?

Colson makes clear that he intends to answer the “worldview questions” from a Christian perspective as evidenced by what might be considered his “thesis statement” for the book:

For Christianity is, after all, a reasonable faith, solidly grounded in human experience. It provides a worldview that fits the structure of reality and enables us to live in harmony with that structure.

Charles Colson. How Now Shall We Live? (Kindle Locations 129-130). Kindle Edition.

Colson is not willing to let Christians “off the hook” simply because they claim to adhere to a specific belief system, however. In several different places he contrasts the “belief” side of Christian faith, with the “deed” side of Christian faith, which I have summarized below:

Soteriological

justification by faith
private belief
prayer, worship, etc.
saving grace
salvation

Cosmological

God’s sovereignty over all
life system
redeem culture
common grace
counteracting results of sin

Colson’s recurring argument is that Christians tend to focus on the first list while neglecting the second list. If a Christian is to make a difference in the world, it will require action. A similar refrain is echoed in the Bible as follows:

… faith by itself, if it is not accompanied by action, is dead.

James 2:17, NIV

Food for Thought

As one who follows Jesus, the introductory chapter of Colson’s book leaves me with some challenging questions:

What is my own worldview and how is it affecting me?
If it is my responsibility to bring to pass God’s common grace to the world, then what do I need to be doing to make that happen?
What about the various other worldviews out there? Are they “just as good” as a Christian worldview?

I’d like to close with the timely words of an author who has influenced me greatly:

I believe in Christianity as I believe that the sun has risen, not only because I see it, but because by it I see everything else.

C.S. Lewis, Weight of Glory, “Is Theology Poetry?”

The post Worldview Matters: Introduction appeared first on Slap the Scissors.

Why Students Fail

Terry Sergeant — Thu, 10 Jan 2013 02:12:21 +0000

A number of my students aren’t willing to “do” without thinking. Good for them.

It brings me little pleasure to admit that I spent a lot of years just doing what I was “supposed to do” without giving much thought to “why” I should do it. Even now, my general tendency is to “do” rather than to “think.” There are definite benefits to such an approach to life. For example, I managed to avoid a lot of pitfalls along the way because I never went far from the road labeled “safe, successful, and proven.” I’ve never be sidelined by drugs or alcohol or gambling or jail. As a young man I more-or-less devoted myself to studies and ended up with a Ph.D. in computer science by age 26. And the list of safe and boring life choices could go on for some time.

The down side of being a goody-two-shoes doer is that it is easy to miss the point/purpose of this thing called life. While the safe road might be good, there may be other roads that are great! If you reach the end of the road and all you have to show for your journey is a house in the suburbs then what did you really accomplish?

It is Perplexing

A number of my students aren’t willing to “do” without thinking. Good for them. Some of them, though, do get sidelined … and that bothers me … a lot. I’ve spent a lot time over years trying to figure out why students fail. To be honest, it is perplexing. The student has left their home to come live on a university campus for the purpose of earning a college degree. They have essentially dedicated four years of their life to this purpose. They have also dedicated major financial resources, in many cases, taking on debt in order to achieve this goal. This same student will then proceed to skip class, ignore homework assignments, and ultimately fail courses. The result is that they pay over $2,000 for the privilege of failing each course. As I often point out to my struggling students: “There are much cheaper ways not to attend a course. Just don’t sign up for it and you can ‘not attend’ it for free!”

As I often point out … “There are much cheaper ways not to attend a course. Just don’t sign up for it and you can ‘not attend’ it for free!”

It is important to add that these students are not stupid. That makes their behavior all the more confounding! Somewhere along my journey of teaching I decided to stop wondering why students failed and to start asking them. I’ll sit down with a student and ask: “Why aren’t you doing well in this class?” You’d think their answers would provide clarity … but they typically don’t. Answers to such questions occasionally have an excuse component (e.g., “I’ve was sick two days”), but almost always have a re-dedication component (“I’ll do better in the future”). Although the re-dedications are, I believe, sincere, they tend not to be long-lived.

I used to chalk up student failure to laziness and lack of academic preparation. While those can be contributing factors, they are not to blame in most cases. On the “lack of academic preparation” issue I would point out that schools have admissions requirements for the purpose of making sure that students who attend have a reasonable shot a completing a degree. If you have been admitted to a college then that college believes you have what it takes to succeed there!

Laziness, on the other hand, can overcome even the brightest mind! Generally, though, the students who fail in my courses I would not characterize as being lazy. Based on my observations the main reasons some students struggle in college are these:

Addictions or Distractions
Pyschological Factors
Worldview Crises

Why Students Fail: Addictions/Distractions

When a student stays up all night long to play a new video game … that doesn’t feel to me like laziness! Such a feat requires discipline, concentration, and devotion!

I’m addressing addictions and distractions together because the distinction can be a bit blurry. Certainly addiction to drugs or alcohol can be disastrous to a college career. I believe these to be relatively rare among the students who enter my classroom. Why students fail my classes is more likely an addiction to social media … or video games … or entertainment … or exercise.

According to Wikipedia (the source of all true wisdom and knowlege):

Classic hallmarks of addiction include: impaired control over substances/behavior, preoccupation with substance/behavior, continued use despite consequences, and denial. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Addiction)

When a student stays up all night long to play a new video game even though they have lots of homework, that doesn’t feel to me like laziness! Such a feat requires discipline, concentration, and devotion! The same student who displays such devotion to the video game will often sleep through my classes (present or not), fail to turn in homework, and perform poorly on exams. Looking back at the “hallmarks of addiction”, the student I just described seems to exhibit impaired control over behavior and to be preoccupied with a game despite the consequences. All we seem to be missing is denial. Well, if you want denial just talk to the student about their addiction:

Professor: “George, I missed you in class yesterday. Is everything okay?”

George: “Oh, yeah, I’m fine. The initial release of (insert game-of-choice here) was at midnight and me and my friends stayed up to play it. It was amazing! (insert loooong-episode-of-describing-specific-events-in-an-imaginary-world-filled-with-imaginary-beings-with-lots-of-imaginary-verbs-used-to-describe-actions here)”

(I should add at this point that there does not appear to be any denial … after all the student is freely admitting what they have done. Fear not. Denial is on its way!)

Professor: “I’m concerned that (insert game-of-choice here) is causing you to do poorly in this class.”

George: “Aww. No, I don’t really play that much. This was just a one-time deal because the game was new. After a few days I’ll be back to normal.”

(There it is!)

In my experience, George will fail my course or, at least, perform way below his potential. Also, in my experience, his absenteeism is much more likely to increase than it is to subside. And my experience would dictate that his failure to turn in one assignment is much more likely to represent a pattern than to be an isolated occurrence!

I think the challenge here is that there is nothing inherently wrong with social media, video games, entertainment, or exercise. They are all socially acceptable and behaviors consistent with well-adjusted people. Nevertheless, George, displays the behaviors associated with an addiction. In such cases I think naming the addiction and treating it as an addiction are necessary steps to progress. Good luck getting George to agree with me on this.

Why Students Fail: Psychological Factors

For a student to move away from home to live in an academy and to pay huge amounts of money to do so is impressive. For that same student to fail a course is tragic.

The main psychological issues that affect my students are homesickness, stress, and depression. I don’t have as much to say about these as they seem to be better understood than addictions. I do think, though, that depression can be especially insidious because it inhibits the very behaviors that are its remedy. I should add at this point, that I’m not talking about clinical depression. If someone is struggling with clinical depression they are typically aware of that prior to coming to college and they often have medication and other coping techniques before coming to college.

Also, these factors are interrelated. A student does poorly on an exam … causing stress … causing “escaping” behaviors … causing more poor performance … causing more stress … causing depression … causing withdrawal … and so the depression become entrenched.

Why Students Fail: Worldview Crises

Yes, addictions, depression, over-commitment, and laziness can contribute significantly to a student’s demise. But from an instructor’s perspective, having a student fail a course, in most cases, represents a misappropriation of priorities. For a student to move away from home to live in an academy and to pay substantial amounts of money to do so is impressive. For that same student to fail a course is incongruent. Student failure implies that the vision that caused them to make such a breathtaking commitment in the first place has been lost. That is to say, when things get busy … when the pressure is on … when assignments are hard … when classes are boring … a student will tend to act according to their worldview. The non-thinking goody-two-shoes doer will stay on task (if not for the right reasons). The student who lives for pleasure will follow the path of the most immediate pleasure. The student who responds to the loudest voice will be drawn to loud voices and then will do what they say. The student who doesn’t have an answer to the question “why am I here?” will drift.

The issue of worldview is paramount.

The issue of worldview is paramount. If a student’s worldview drives them to forsake short-term comforts for longer-term benefits they are less likely to be derailed by distractions, addictions, or difficulties. In fact, I would go so far as to say that in many cases, distractions, addictions, and difficulties are symptoms of an ineffective worldview. As the previous sentence implies, my own worldview doesn’t ascribe equal standing to all worldviews! I would like to address this issue of one’s worldview in greater depth. To do so I will create a series of posts dedicated to the topic.

The post Why Students Fail appeared first on Slap the Scissors.

Second Semester Blues

Terry Sergeant — Tue, 11 Dec 2012 20:21:38 +0000

… [some] students make it through their first semester on the fumes of adrenaline and the good habits they built in high school …

“College is a blast!” I’ve heard quite a few variations on that theme over the years. And it’s true: College is a truly exciting and transformational time for most people who are afforded the privilege. As a somewhat seasoned professor I can also tell you that the Freshman year of college can be quite stressful. The fact is that a number of students really struggle with the many pressures and end up either dropping out after their first semester or in the middle of the second semester they get a case of the “second semester blues.” Second semester blues is my term for a drop in academic performance during the second semester.

I used to think that if a student finished their first semester in good standing then they were set for a successful college career. (I used to think similarly about marriage!) As it turns out a number of students make it through their first semester on the fumes of adrenaline and the good habits they built in high school with the help of parents.

Obviously, each student’s experience is different, but it seems go something like this:

… being “scared” is not a sustainable motivator.

The first-semester freshman is typically concerned about whether or not they have the “academic goods” to succeed. Also, fresh on their ears, is advice, encouragement, (and threats) from family. So, there is a sense in which a new college student can be “scared straight”. Those pressures are not inherently bad, of course. The problem is that being “scared” is not a sustainable motivator. Besides, one of the major themes of the college experience is freedom. Students are suddenly in charge of many decisions that heretofore had been made for them. They now decide:

when to go to bed

when to get up

when, where and what, and how much to eat

how to spend their free time

how fast to drive

… and a lot more!

One behavior that sometimes moves from the status of “mandatory” to “optional” is class attendance. Missing class in high school typically comes with immediate (negative) feedback. Missing class in college comes with … well … nothing … at least in the short term. As students begin to realize that they truly are free some of them exercise that freedom to their detriment. The ultimate cost of non-attendance is, of course, poor grades. Poor grades, can dampen enthusiasm for study, which will lead to increased emphasis on “other things”, which leads to poorer grades … and so the cycle continues resulting a dire case of second semester blues!

The Cure

So, what is the cure for the second semester blues? I think the cure depends on a variety of factors. Perhaps the root of the problem is the tendency we all have to do things that aren’t necessarily in our best interest. An ancient writer, Paul of Tarsus, expresses this idea eloquently:

What I don’t understand about myself is that I decide one way, but then I act another, doing things I absolutely despise. So if I can’t be trusted to figure out what is best for myself and then do it, it becomes obvious that God’s command is necessary. (The Bible, Romans 7:15-16, “The Message” Translation)

Another aspect of the cure may involve fleshing out one’s world view.

If you or someone you care about is struggling with addictions or lack of motivation there very well could be spiritual roots to the problem. You might find it helpful to read the struggle Paul of Tarsus describes and then his resolution.

Another aspect of the cure may involve fleshing out one’s worldview.For more on the importance of your worldview, visit my post on “Why Students Fail” Some students are so eager to enjoy their new found freedom, they fail to ask important questions such as:

“Why am I here?” (in college, in life)

“When college is over, what do I want to have accomplished?”

“When my life is over, what do I want to have accomplished?”

“What is the point of it all?”

Final Thoughts

If you happen to be a student (in any semester) who is struggling, let me encourage you to take some time to evaluate why you came to college in the first place. If your goal is to have a good time, let me assure there are much cheaper and easier ways to have a good time! On the other hand, if you are studying for a purpose, take time to reflect on that purpose. And if you need help to get out of a hole, don’t let pride keep you from getting the help you need.

The post Second Semester Blues appeared first on Slap the Scissors.